.jpeg)
What Is Revit and How Is It Used in MEP Design?
Revit software is Autodesk’s flagship tool for Building Information Modelling (BIM). It enables professionals to plan, design, and document building systems in a 3D environment. Specifically, Revit MEP software is tailored for mechanical, electrical, and plumbing engineers.
When it comes to MEP design, Revit MEP lets you create intelligent components, simulate systems, and automatically update changes across the model. It brings immense value to MEP drafting software workflows by enabling parametric modelling, system analysis, and automated schedules.
MEP engineers use Revit MEP for designing HVAC ductwork, electrical panels, plumbing networks, and fire protection systems. Its strength lies in visualising and simulating real-world performance, helping avoid MEP design mistakes early in the process.
Moreover, Revit architecture integrates seamlessly with Revit MEP, allowing architects and engineers to work in tandem. The unified platform ensures that updates on one end reflect across disciplines, reducing the risk of miscommunication.
What Is Navisworks and Where Does It Fit in MEP Workflows?
Navisworks is a project review tool used primarily for model aggregation, clash detection, and construction simulation. It enables users to integrate 3D models from various disciplines, architectural, structural, and MEP, into a single environment.
This tool is invaluable during the coordination phase of MEP projects. By importing models from Revit software and other platforms, Navisworks software enables design and construction teams to identify potential clashes, such as an HVAC duct running through a beam, before they reach the site.
Beyond just detection, it also facilitates team collaboration, offering features like issue tracking, comments, viewpoints, and animations. This makes Navisworks an indispensable part of MEP BIM modelling and MEP design software workflows, especially on large and complex projects.
It does not generate design models like Revit MEP, but instead refines, reviews, and prepares them for the build phase, making it the perfect companion in the MEP software toolkit.
Revit vs Navisworks
Let us now look at the real comparison of Revit vs Navisworks in tabular form:
|
Feature/Function |
Revit MEP |
Navisworks Software |
|
Primary Purpose |
Design and modelling of MEP systems |
Model coordination, clash detection, and simulation |
|
User Group |
MEP engineers, designers, architects |
Project managers, coordinators, BIM modellers |
|
File Format Support |
RVT (native), IFC |
NWD, NWF supports multiple model types, including RVT |
|
Clash Detection |
Basic (limited) |
Advanced clash detection across disciplines |
|
Collaboration |
Live collaboration in the cloud via BIM 360 |
Aggregation and issue tracking post-model import |
|
Simulation |
System performance, load calculations |
4D simulation and construction planning |
|
Output |
Construction-ready designs and documents |
Coordination models, clash reports, timelines |
|
Learning Curve |
Steeper (technical and design-intensive) |
Easier (mainly review and coordination tasks) |
Which Tool Supports Better Collaboration and Clash Detection?
When it comes to team coordination and detecting design conflicts, Navisworks software takes the lead. Its clash detection engine is far more potent than what Revit MEP offers. While Revit MEP allows for some level of interference checking, it lacks the comprehensive clash reporting features that Navisworks is known for.
Furthermore, Navisworks shines in environments where multiple stakeholders are involved. You can import Revit MEP, Revit architecture, structural models, and even CAD files into a single coordinated model. This provides the entire team, designers, fabricators, contractors, and site managers, with a holistic view of the project.
Its collaboration features, such as Timeliner (for 4D simulation), redlining, and viewpoint sharing, make it a central hub during project coordination meetings. In MEP works in construction, where accuracy and coordination can make or break a timeline, Navisworks software becomes essential.
That said, Revit MEP also supports real-time cloud collaboration through Autodesk Construction Cloud, allowing multiple users to work on the same model simultaneously. This makes it ideal for the design phase, but it is still limited when it comes to project-wide coordination.
When Should MEP Professionals Use Revit vs Navisworks?
Let us break it down based on use cases:
Use Revit MEP when
- You are at the MEP design or documentation stage.
- You need to perform system analysis or simulate HVAC and electrical performance.
- You are generating construction documents, schedules, and equipment layouts.
- You are applying for Revit MEP jobs and need strong design skills.
- You are part of a design team using MEP design software to create coordinated layouts.
Use Navisworks software when:
- The design is complete, and the project moves into the coordination phase.
- You need to conduct detailed clash detection between architectural, structural, and MEP engineering models.
- You are planning site activities or simulating construction timelines.
- You are working on large-scale MEP infrastructure projects with multiple stakeholders.
- You need a central model viewer that integrates input from various MEP drafting software platforms.
Ultimately, both tools play crucial yet distinct roles within the MEP industry. Many projects begin in Revit MEP and transition to Navisworks software as they move into execution. Mastering both can give professionals a serious edge in MEP BIM modelling and BIM software coordination workflows.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
